Difference between revisions of "Thoughts On Categories"
m |
m |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
''Gads, there are way too many categories for most of the articles and many of them either don't make sense or are too broad.'' | ''Gads, there are way too many categories for most of the articles and many of them either don't make sense or are too broad.'' | ||
| − | === Possible One Time Solution === | + | === Possible One-Time Solution === |
* Look at adult categories and use the existing categories to tag all of these pages "AdultContent" | * Look at adult categories and use the existing categories to tag all of these pages "AdultContent" | ||
* Identify and store all category names in which there are more than 1,000 references (VeryGeneralCategories) | * Identify and store all category names in which there are more than 1,000 references (VeryGeneralCategories) | ||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
* Ability to "Delete a worthless category" - which would delete all instances of a worthless category | * Ability to "Delete a worthless category" - which would delete all instances of a worthless category | ||
* Ability to "Rename a category" - which would rename all instances of a category to another name | * Ability to "Rename a category" - which would rename all instances of a category to another name | ||
| − | ** For user created categories this may not always be what we want to do. i.e. if there are two categories that mean basically the same thing like "Table Tennis" and "Ping Pong", it may be fine to let them both exist because that will continue to match the [[Folksonomy|folksonomy]] that people have created. Where this utility may be useful is in renaming some of the major categories that were prepopulated to categories that are more wiki-ish. | + | ** For user-created categories this may not always be what we want to do. i.e. if there are two categories that mean basically the same thing like "Table Tennis" and "Ping Pong", it may be fine to let them both exist because that will continue to match the [[Folksonomy|folksonomy]] that people have created. Where this utility may be useful is in renaming some of the major categories that were prepopulated to categories that are more wiki-ish. |
Revision as of 19:47, 12 May 2007
Trimming them down
Gads, there are way too many categories for most of the articles and many of them either don't make sense or are too broad.
Possible One-Time Solution
- Look at adult categories and use the existing categories to tag all of these pages "AdultContent"
- Identify and store all category names in which there are more than 1,000 references (VeryGeneralCategories)
- Delete these categories because they are too bulky and not helpful to users
- Delete all singleton categories (where there is only one page with that category) because these are likely too narrow
- The AboutUsBot should not create categories in new records that match the "VeryGeneralCategories"
- When a user creates a new category, if it is a "VeryGeneralCategory" then they should be warned about that before saving (but still allowed if they want). This will actually give an opportunity to some people to "capture" a general category such as "Real Estate" but I'm not sure what to do about that.
Category Utilities
- Ability to "Delete a worthless category" - which would delete all instances of a worthless category
- Ability to "Rename a category" - which would rename all instances of a category to another name
- For user-created categories this may not always be what we want to do. i.e. if there are two categories that mean basically the same thing like "Table Tennis" and "Ping Pong", it may be fine to let them both exist because that will continue to match the folksonomy that people have created. Where this utility may be useful is in renaming some of the major categories that were prepopulated to categories that are more wiki-ish.
